Documentary Brings Ohio's Elephant in the Room Out of the Shadows

A new documentary by Michael Webber has been getting a lot of attention at film festivals this year. The Elephant in the Living Room brings the issue of privately owned lions and tigers and bears (and reptiles and other wild animals) to the big screen.

In an interview with CityBeat, Webber said exotic pet ownership may be shocking, but it's not an obscure phenomenon. "I started paying attention and that's when I realized this was the elephant in the living room. This big, enormous thing that's going on in our country and no one is really recognizing it."

Until now.

It's no coincidence that the Dayton, Ohio, filmmaker aimed the camera at his own state. Ohio has some of the weakest exotic animal laws in the country, a flaw which gained national attention this summer when a bear killed his caretaker. Despite obvious and repeated negligence on the part of the bear's owner, Sam Mazzola, authorities' hands were tied because you can pretty much own whatever you want in Ohio. And Mazzola isn't the only one whose choice of pets has caused problems.

"It's like the wild, wild west in the State of Ohio," Tim Harrison of Outreach for Animals told WKRC Local 12 in Cincinnati. Harrison is a police officer, firefighter and paramedic from the city of Oakwood. He's also the go-to guy when it comes to exotic animals, fielding as many as 200 calls a year, and he's one of the stars of The Elephant in the Living Room.

On the other side of the equation, the film follows Terry Brumfield, who keeps two African lions, hand-raised since they were cubs.

Webber says following the personal stories of Harrison and Brumfield "has a completely different effect on people from an entertainment standpoint, from an education and awareness standpoint, you take it personally. When people get affected in that way, that's when the awareness starts to explode."

The explosion of The Elephant in the Living Room comes just in time. Although this issue plays out across the country, it's been stampeding across Ohio politics lately, especially since Governor Ted Strickland promised an exotic pets ban as part of a package deal of animal welfare reforms negotiated with the Humane Society of the United States and Ohio's Farm Bureau.

The proposal was applauded by several animal welfare groups, but various contingents protested, from reptile enthusiasts to schools with wild mascots. Some, like Brumfield, feel their wild animals are their children; others feel they simply have a right to own whatever animal they want.

It's likely that an exotic pet ban in Ohio would grandfather in existing animals, with the caveat that troublemakers like Mazzola could finally be held accountable. This Midwest state has been the wild west for too long; it's dangerous for people and unfair to the animals. Tell Ohio legislators to pass the exotic pet ban.

Harrison's opinion is clear: "When you bring a dangerous large predator, snake, bear, crocodile, anything of that nature, you're signing a death warrant for either you or the animal ... one of you is going to die."

The website for the documentary calls it "a movie too big to ignore." Let's hope so.

The Elephant in the Living Room is currently screening in Cincinnati, Ohio. If you're not in The Buckeye State, don't worry: the movie is due for nationwide release in early 2011.

Photo credit: eMaringolo